|
Debunking The Gun Control Myth
Gary Mauser - Simon
Fraser University News
Burnaby,
British Columbia
"The results of my research," says
Professor Gary Mauser, "first, made a skeptic of me about the usefulness of
gun control laws, and then, later, convinced me that firearm ownership was a
social good." Mauser is the recipient of the 2001 Nora and Ted Sterling
Prize in Support of Controversy for his research on gun control.
The
treacherous attack on the World Trade Center on Sept. 11 opened our eyes.
Canadians now realize that our government can't protect us. The government's
efforts to control violence have been badly misdirected. It was not wise to
freeze the RCMP budget for a decade, slash CSIS, let violent criminals roam
around on probation, and eliminate the Vancouver port police. And for what?
To create a massive bureaucracy to register the guns of ordinary Canadian
citizens. Not many of my colleagues at SFU have supported me during the past
15 years that I have pursued my research into gun control.
When I started, I knew little about guns. What I
did know, I'd learned from television: guns were scary, and gun owners were
dangerous. I remember thinking that tighter gun laws would probably help to
reduce gun crime. The results of my research, first, made a skeptic of me
about the usefulness of gun control laws, and then, later, convinced me that
firearm ownership was a social good. Here are some of the facts that helped
change my mind. |
Self-defense incidents are all but
invisible to authorities. The participants have no motive to report them to
the police, and indeed every reason to keep them quiet. Defensive gun use
doesn't mean Hollywood-style shoot-outs. Surprise: television doesn't
reflect real life.
Research in the U.S. shows that more than 95 % of the times a gun is used in
self-protection, the gun is not fired but merely displayed. There is no
victim. Little empirical support can be mustered that Canadian gun laws keep
us safe. American criminologists widely admit that solid empirical research
showing that any gun law has had a significant effect on crime rates is
lacking. Many researchers are very disappointed.
Handguns have been registered for more than 60 years in Canada, but handgun
crime is increasing. At the same time that homicides have been declining,
handgun homicides have increased from about 25 % to more than 50 % of gun
homicides. The Solicitor General admitted in Parliament that handgun
registration has never been useful in solving a crime.
Firearm
registration fails the test of good police strategy. In order to stop
violent criminals, society needs the support of gun owners.
|